HR leaders at large firms knew that in 2016 compliance with health care regulations wouldn't be inexpensive or easy. Affordable Care Act (ACA) compliance cost projections for the 2015 reporting season reflected this fact. According to the Society for Human Resource Management (SHRM), 33 percent of employers predicted 2016 would be the most expensive year for compliance efforts because of reporting, disclosure and notification requirements. With the excise tax on high-value health plans, also known as the Cadillac tax, set to take effect in 2020, the 2015 reporting season presented steep learning curves for many organizations.

Here, we explore whether HR leaders' ACA cost estimates were accurate in 2016 and whether compliance proved more challenging than expected.

ACA Compliance Budgets in 2016

Few HR leaders doubted that ACA compliance would take a fair amount of effort in 2016. According to SHRM, in addition to the Cadillac tax, the predicted costliest actions between 2016 and 2018 are as follows:

  • Administrative functions
  • Reporting costs
  • Disclosure and notification requirements

The resources required to comply during the 2015 reporting season have led to structural changes at some HR organizations, according to SHRM. Some businesses have appointed official ACA compliance managers, and many could have larger ACA compliance cost projections for the 2016 reporting season.

ACA Challenges in 2016

Regardless of where your specific organization fell in terms of costs, few HR leaders would likely describe the 2015 reporting season as a simple experience. Even if your organization didn't need to make any adjustments to employee contributions in order to meet affordability criteria, you may have experienced issues with your infrastructure. Common struggles for employers could have been related to reporting compliance and the necessary infrastructure. At some organizations, this might have included the following difficulties:

  • Knowing what to report to the IRS
  • Accessing data from warehousing systems
  • Collecting data
  • Data quality

Too much focus on meeting basic requirements because of insufficient infrastructure means some organizations may not have been able to comply with more complex requirements. Requirements that could fall to the wayside if there are data retrieval issues include written notification of plan cancellations if employees commit fraud or compliant notification of patient protections.

ACA Compliance Costs in 2017

Few HR leaders are willing to publicly reveal how their ACA compliance spending stacked up to their initial budget, but most will agree that 2015's reporting season offered invaluable lessons for the future, despite the IRS' reporting extension. While the Cadillac tax is no longer lurking around the corner, HR leaders are entering 2017 with a better understanding of the kinds of financial and technological resources they'll need to comply. And for employers that choose not to file but should have, this year, the IRS has started sending out Requests for Employers Reporting of Offers of Coverage of Health Insurance Coverage (Forms 1094-C and 1095-C) to employers that they think may have been Applicable Large Employers (ALEs) in 2015, but the IRS has yet to receive the returns. These need to be responded to within 30 days.

Determining employee eligibility and meeting reporting requirements is challenging, and employers can face expanded risk exposure if their data is unavailable or inaccurate. For the upcoming year, ensuring you have the right HCM systems in place to meet complex requirements with accuracy is critical.

Want to learn more about 2017's HR trends? See below for the other articles in our #HR2017 series:

#HR2017: What We Learned About Benefit Policies in 2016

#HR2017: Can't Miss Info About the FMLA

#HR2017: What Last Year Taught Us About the ACA

#HR2017: Top Innovation Trends Coming This Year

#HR2017: Help Your Employees Achieve Their Health and Wellness Resolutions

#HR2017: What's on the Horizon for Workplace Flexibility in the Coming Year?

#HR2017: Job Growth Patterns from 2016 Inform 2017's Outlook

#HR2017: Talent Acquisition Trends for 2017 — Tips to Attract Rock Stars