---
title: "Is AI Changing the Way Early Career Employees Build Experience? | SPARK Blog | ADP"
description: "Explore how AI is changing entry-level work, early-career development, and the future talent pipeline, with practical questions HR leaders can use to protect critical learning opportunities."
---

[Trends](/spark/trends)

# Is AI Changing the Way Early-Career Employees Build Experience?

[![Cat DiStasio](/-/media/adp/blog/contributors/c/a/cat-distasio_851291.jpg?h=300&iar=0&w=300&rev=09988409c19b4f92930bef959fcd4730&hash=10824FDE824D5A582B9D64BBFAF6CFF6)Cat DiStasio](/spark/contributors?name=cat+distasio&id=49735f1f-7464-4fe7-aa8e-e662bb1f98c1)

-   [Share Spark Article on LinkedIn](https://www.linkedin.com/shareArticle?mini=true&url=https://www.adp.com/spark/articles/2026/11/is-ai-changing-the-way-early-career-employees-build-experience&title=Is%20AI%20Changing%20the%20Way%20Early-Career%20Employees%20Build%20Experience%3F&summary=%3Cp%3EEntry-level%20work%20serves%20two%20purposes%3A%20completing%20tasks%20today%20and%20helping%20employees%20develop%20the%20knowledge%20and%20judgment%20they%20will%20need%20tomorrow.%20Through%20it%2C%20early-career%20employees%20learn%20how%20organizations%20operate%2C%20evaluate%20information%20and%20navigate%20ambiguity.%20Research%20from%20%3Ca%20href%3D%22https%3A%2F%2Fwww.adpresearch.com%2Fresearch%2Fcanaries-dashboard-2026-june%22%20target%3D%22_blank%22%3E%3Cu%3EADP%20and%20Stanford%20University%E2%80%99s%20Digital%20Economy%20Lab%3C%2Fu%3E%3C%2Fa%3E%20has%20identified%20employment%20declines%20among%20younger%20workers%20in%20occupations%20highly%20exposed%20to%20artificial%20intelligence%20\(AI\)%2C%20as%20a%20direct%20result%20of%20reduced%20hiring.%20%3C%2Fp%3E&source=in1.com)
-   [Share Spark Article on Facebook](http://www.facebook.com/share.php?u=https://www.adp.com/spark/articles/2026/11/is-ai-changing-the-way-early-career-employees-build-experience)
-   [Share Spark Article on Twitter](https://twitter.com/intent/tweet?url=https://www.adp.com/spark/articles/2026/11/is-ai-changing-the-way-early-career-employees-build-experience&text=Is%20AI%20Changing%20the%20Way%20Early-Career%20Employees%20Build%20Experience%3F)
-   [Share Spark Article via Email](mailto:?subject=Is%20AI%20Changing%20the%20Way%20Early-Career%20Employees%20Build%20Experience%3F&body=https://www.adp.com/spark/articles/2026/11/is-ai-changing-the-way-early-career-employees-build-experience)
-   Print Spark Article

![Is AI Changing the Way Early-Career Employees Build Experience?](/-/media/adp/blog/articles/featuredimages/b/c/bcb2d6ad-7b1e-4df6-a865-0ee9434c6045_is-ai-changing-the-way-early-career-employees-build-experience.jpg?h=458&iar=0&w=815&rev=66930977bee345eb93b21f5f620927c6&hash=FC98CA5BB124A536B8F22EA6E3CB7032)

Entry-level work serves two purposes: completing tasks today and helping employees develop the knowledge and judgment they will need tomorrow. Through it, early-career employees learn how organizations operate, evaluate information and navigate ambiguity. Research from [ADP and Stanford University’s Digital Economy Lab](https://www.adpresearch.com/research/canaries-dashboard-2026-june) has identified employment declines among younger workers in occupations highly exposed to artificial intelligence (AI), as a direct result of reduced hiring.

As AI changes how some of that early-career work gets done, a less obvious question emerges: If employees have fewer opportunities to learn through the tasks they once performed, how will they develop the experience needed to become increasingly capable contributors and future leaders?

Employers need to preserve early-career opportunities to build skills like judgment and foresight. To learn more about the future of early-career development, we spoke with Frances Chumney, PhD, head of applied research, measurement and analytics for StandOut at ADP, and Vinothini (Vino) Ambrose, director of talent strategic advisory and leader development facilitation services at ADP. 

The findings raise a new question for HR leaders: How do we determine where to use AI if we want to ensure early-career employees can still [develop meaningful skills](https://www.adp.com/spark/articles/2024/12/embracing-skills-getting-practical-with-skills-focused-hiring-and-development.aspx)?

## Key takeaways

-   Reduced employment among early-career workers in AI-exposed occupations is an early signal to monitor, although the data does not establish AI as the cause.
    
-   Entry-level work helps employees develop critical thinking, judgment, pattern recognition and organizational awareness.
    
-   Organizational leaders can make wiser choices about AI adoption by examining not only which tasks can be automated, but also which developmental experiences those tasks provide.
    

## What the workforce evidence is telling us to pay attention to

The [Canaries Dashboard](https://www.adpresearch.com/research/canaries-dashboard-2026-june), a collaboration between ADP Research and Stanford’s Digital Economy Lab, tracks employment trends across occupations with varying levels of AI exposure. Its purpose is to identify early signals in the labor market that might otherwise be obscured by broader employment trends.

In its July 2026 update, ADP Research reported that employment among workers ages 22 to 25 in highly AI-exposed occupations had declined 4.3% year over year, marking 33 consecutive months of contraction.

Among workers in the same age group in occupations least exposed to AI, employment remained flat. The dashboard also showed declines among workers ages 26 to 30 in highly exposed occupations, while employment grew among their counterparts in the least-exposed occupations.

The same research revealed that employment among younger software developers and customer service representatives has declined. But less AI-exposed occupations, such as home-health aides, have shown more favorable trends.

The findings do not establish that AI is causing the employment declines. The dashboard tracks relationships between occupational AI exposure and employment trends in a large sample of employers using ADP payroll services. It cannot isolate AI from every other factor influencing hiring.

Still, the differences warrant attention, particularly because they are more pronounced among younger workers than older age groups.

“The ADP/Stanford research gives us an early signal,” Ambrose said. “It's not concluding anything necessarily, but it's telling us to pay attention to something.”

The dashboard also underscores the distinction between AI that automates work and AI that complements it. For employers, that raises a question: When AI changes early-career tasks, what happens to the experience employees would otherwise gain through them?

## Entry-level work is about much more than tasks

Employees learn to make decisions, assess priorities, collaborate and understand context through everyday responsibilities. Training and mentoring help, but much learning comes through practice, feedback and correcting mistakes.

Ambrose sees this process as essential to building judgment. A new employee might make assumptions that need to be reconsidered or overlook a consequence of certain choices.

“I hope \[early-career employees\] don't do it correctly right off the bat,” Ambrose said, “because there is so much to be learned from trying something and having to approach it again from a totally different angle.”

That learning process helps employees recognize what they have missed and test whether a solution addresses the problem. Experienced contributors and [business leaders](https://www.adp.com/spark/articles/2021/07/whats-fallen-off-organizations-radars-strategic-workforce-planning-for-succession-and-leadership.aspx) must evaluate alternatives, anticipate consequences and understand how decisions affect people and the business. Employers need to protect the experiences that help early-career employees build those skills. 

Critical thinking is another key capability developed early in a career. Employees must cultivate the ability to forecast outcomes and understand the role other factors might play.

“Critical thinking isn’t just about making the best choice in the moment,” Chumney said. “It is also about being able to anticipate consequences and understand how other people factor into the conversation.”

Early-career employees contribute while they learn, too. Ambrose notes that they can spot the patterns that more experienced colleagues may overlook, helping teams improve products and customer experiences. In fields like retail, hospitality and health care, those observations can inform how organizations respond to customer needs and operational challenges.

Supporting organizational learning and innovation — as well as on-the-job skill development — makes entry-level work valuable beyond simple task completion.

### [_Learn how to reframe your talent strategy with a people-centered approach - get our guide._](https://www.adp.com/resources/articles-and-insights/articles/t/talent-strategy)

## When the work changes, how does experience keep up?

AI can accelerate many of the tasks that have traditionally occupied the time of early-career employees. That includes gathering information and analyzing data to preparing initial drafts of reports and recommendations. But saving time on a task does not automatically translate into an equivalent opportunity to develop the skills associated with performing it.

Ambrose asks us to consider an HR analyst investigating high employee turnover. Traditionally, the work might involve collecting disparate data, comparing employee populations, identifying patterns, reviewing exit interviews and interviewing employees to understand what the numbers reveal.

AI can consolidate information, identify patterns and generate an initial analysis quickly. The analyst must still assess accuracy, question apparent relationships and identify what else is needed to understand the problem.

An initial analysis might suggest one explanation for turnover. But correlation does not necessarily establish causation. So the analyst must use judgment to challenge the interpretation and investigate what is happening in the organization. That might mean speaking with employees or examining management practices and expectations.

“The opportunity to develop the ability to interpret information and really understand business context and challenge what they're seeing is the part that we need to make sure we preserve,” Ambrose said.

The same question applies to research roles. Chumney described a recent graduate with a master’s degree in human resource management starting an entry-level HR research position.

Traditionally, the researcher might conduct literature reviews, code data, run basic statistical analyses, summarize findings and draft reports. Through that work, they would learn to evaluate research, synthesize information and think critically about methodology.

“Now, every AI assistant can do all of those tasks in almost no time at all,” Chumney said. “So where do those same developmentally valuable learnings come from for that new researcher?”

The answer is not to isolate every task from AI. A researcher might employ AI tools to spend less time preparing an analysis and more testing its assumptions or discussing implications with experienced colleagues. This is valuable learning if the employee has the knowledge and guidance to engage critically.

The point is not that these new approaches will necessarily produce better development. It is that organizations should examine whether they do. Both Ambrose and Chumney caution that it is too early to draw firm conclusions about how AI is changing early career development. Workplace policies and norms around AI use are still evolving, and the longer-term effects will take time to understand.

## An opportunity to be more intentional about experience

HR leaders can start by understanding [how employees develop experience](https://www.adp.com/resources/articles-and-insights/articles/t/talent-development-strategy.aspx) today before deciding how AI should change their work — and considering how AI impacts [the employee experience](https://www.adp.com/spark/articles/2026/01/key-employee-experience-trends-for-2026-and-how-to-prioritize.aspx). Ambrose recommends examining what is actually happening rather than immediately prescribing a solution.

Look beyond job descriptions to identify the capabilities employees develop through their responsibilities. A routine task may expose them to decision making, teach them to compare approaches or show when to seek more information. That distinction can guide decisions about where AI belongs and how to structure remaining work.

Questions for HR leaders include:

-   **What do employees learn through their current responsibilities?** Look beyond the deliverable to identify the judgment, problem-solving skills and organizational knowledge gained through the process.
    
-   **Which experiences matter most during the first six to 12 months?** Consider how new employees learn to navigate ambiguity, evaluate information, collaborate and understand good performance.
    
-   **How might AI change those learning opportunities?** Identify where automation could remove repetitive work while also impacting or reducing opportunities to practice foundational skills.
    
-   **How will employees build capabilities that remain important?** Consider different assignments, guided analysis, feedback, discussions with experienced colleagues or progressively more complex responsibilities.
    
-   **How will leaders know whether development is happening?** Ensure managers understand what skills they are expected to develop and whether performance expectations account for the work AI now performs.
    

If AI changes how a task is completed, employers may need to reconsider what they expect from an entry-level employee. Someone who no longer spends hours assembling data might spend more time interpreting results — but only if they receive the context, guidance and opportunities necessary to do so.

Managers also need to distinguish between employees who use AI to deepen their understanding and those who rely on it to bypass the thinking required. Both may produce a similar initial deliverable, but the developmental outcomes could differ.

Chumney said more research is needed to understand employers' motivations and awareness of potential trade-offs. Within each organization, leaders should explain which tools employees can use and why independent thought and critical evaluation still matter. AI could also support learning when employees use it to explore approaches or test assumptions, then examine the output rather than accept it uncritically.

## The talent pipeline starts with experience

The long-term implications of AI for early-career development remain uncertain. It’s simply too soon to know the full impact. The employment data signals a shift to watch, but it does not establish how employees’ developmental experiences will change or what the consequences might be for their careers in the long term.

That uncertainty is a reason for HR leaders to pay attention now — and take appropriate action.

A [future talent pipeline](https://www.adp.com/spark/articles/2024/06/how-to-craft-your-business-case-for-succession-planning.aspx) depends on more than hiring enough people or identifying the technical skills an organization will need in five or 10 years. It also depends on how employees become experienced contributors: how they develop judgment, learn organizational norms, recognize patterns and understand what matters to the business. These capabilities support increasingly complex responsibilities, leadership, institutional memory and organizational continuity.

As Ambrose points out, succession and workforce planning often focus on where future leaders and experienced employees will come from. Organizations also need to consider where and how those employees will gain the experiences that prepare them for those roles.

“That's a really important focus area that people should be pulling into how they're thinking about talent and AI in general,” Ambrose said.

AI may change the route employees take to become experienced professionals. Some foundational tasks may disappear, others may evolve and new opportunities to learn may emerge. The effects will likely differ across occupations and organizations.

As employers evaluate how AI can improve productivity, they should also examine what employees learn through the work being transformed. Building the future talent pipeline means looking beyond the tasks people perform today to understand how those tasks help them become capable of doing more tomorrow.

## Frequently asked questions

### How is AI changing entry-level work?

AI can automate or accelerate tasks traditionally performed by early-career employees, including gathering information, analyzing data, conducting research and preparing initial drafts of reports. While these efficiencies can free employees to focus on higher-level analysis, they may also reduce opportunities to develop critical thinking, judgment and business context through hands-on experience.

### Why is early-career experience important to the talent pipeline?

Entry-level work helps employees build the skills and organizational knowledge they need to take on increasingly complex responsibilities. Through everyday tasks, feedback and learning from mistakes, employees develop judgment, recognize patterns and understand how their decisions affect the business. These experiences help prepare future experienced contributors and leaders, supporting succession planning and organizational continuity.

### How can employers understand how early-career experience is changing?

Employers can examine how AI is changing day-to-day responsibilities and identify the skills employees traditionally develop through those tasks. HR leaders should look beyond job descriptions and deliverables to understand where employees practice decision making, evaluate information, solve problems and learn business context. Monitoring employment trends can provide additional signals, but employers should avoid assuming that AI alone explains changes in early-career employment.

### What should HR leaders consider as early-career work evolves?

HR leaders should evaluate the productivity benefits of AI and its potential impact on employee development. Key considerations include which tasks provide valuable learning opportunities, which capabilities employees need to develop and how managers can provide guidance, feedback and progressively complex assignments as work changes. Employers should also assess whether employees are using AI to deepen their understanding or bypass the critical thinking needed to build lasting capabilities.

### [Learn how to reframe your talent strategy with a people-centered approach - get our guide.](https://www.adp.com/resources/articles-and-insights/articles/t/talent-strategy)

  

Tags

-   [People Management and Growth](/spark/tags?tag=people+management+and+growth&id=39df9d5f-acef-41f8-b559-e66bd9587edb)
-   [Artificial Intelligence](/spark/tags?tag=artificial+intelligence&id=8df29e24-5ba8-46e4-ad7a-b85be5d637ad)
-   [Career Management](/spark/tags?tag=career+management&id=e4b9fdf9-c72d-4272-9a42-c1e2250ee4f3)
-   [Learning and Development](/spark/tags?tag=learning+and+development&id=3d490a68-1b64-4e60-90d6-3f92f6a5a920)
-   [Succession Planning](/spark/tags?tag=succession+planning&id=3a3cda77-e7b2-44e6-8cef-231569dc018c)
-   [Large Business](/spark/tags?tag=large+business&id=857d287d-616d-4c61-8bb4-9cf3c58dc15f)
-   [Midsize Business](/spark/tags?tag=midsize+business&id=6c3e7f4c-18dd-49b1-a74c-21946207bab5)
-   [Multinational](/spark/tags?tag=multinational&id=1b479405-b3f2-4347-b694-8180e4c848e5)
-   [Small Business](/spark/tags?tag=small+business&id=c0e0db06-ed5a-4835-b80e-76544b8c2000)
-   [Research & Insights](/spark/tags?tag=research+&+insights&id=3cdec194-edd9-4ae6-8b6f-15d8538e26d6)
-   [Articles](/spark/tags?tag=articles&id=cf7240ee-7034-4ef1-9183-0a3dfaa3c44d)

Subscribe to SPARK updates

Stay in the know on the latest workforce trends and insights.

Subscribe Now

## Recommended for You

[Article Topic](#)

[Article Title](#)

[Article Topic](#)

[Article Title](#)

[Article Topic](#)

[Article Title](#)

### Tools & Resources

Take your organization to the next level with practical tools and resources that can help you work smarter.

[Visit Resource Center](/resources)

### Recommend a Topic

Is there a topic or business challenge you would like to see covered on SPARK?

Submit a Topic